Library of Articles

  • Library: Articles

The best Joni Mitchell song she never wrote Print-ready version

by Charles Andrews
Santa Monica Daily Press
November 19, 2014

JONI REDUX, 35 YEARS ON

Last week I wrote about the remarkable convergence, within three days and mostly within Santa Monica's borders, of art exhibitions by three famous musicians, Bob Dylan, Neil Young and Joni Mitchell. The first two shows continue at Bergamot, and I especially recommend the Dylan at Andrew Weiss Gallery, there through early January. The Robert Berman Gallery, besides Neil Young, has a diverse 35th Anniversary Show featuring Dali and Dennis Hopper, Burroughs and Robbie Conal, Man Ray and many others. Ending soon.

Joni Mitchell's show at the Hammer Museum in Westwood was not only her remarkable paintings but a film she edited of a new ballet done to her songs. It was a one-night stand. Which brings me sadly, painfully to unfinished business.

I wrote that I "was unsuccessful in my attempt to get a word with her (Mitchell), face to face. I had a reason. I wanted to test her memory. And my charisma from the old days. And maybe get another date." Then I promised readers "the rest of that story," next column. Yeah, that sounds a bit provocative, I know, but it is a pretty good story (usually my wife brings it up and makes me tell it), though without the hoped for fairytale ending.

Thirty-five years ago Mitchell walked into my dear friend Fay Abrams' Mariposa Gallery in Albuquerque when I still lived there, and bought a goose-shaped tea service for her parents' anniversary. Fay accurately (psychically) predicted when Mitchell would come in to pick it up, and I showed up and trailed her from room to room as she browsed, like a tongue-tied schoolboy, all nerve and brain function drained from my being. I had interviewed and hung out with plenty of big name musicians, but Joni Mitchell was one of my very few music heroes.

I hesitated and hesitated until finally she was out the door with her treasure. My friend gave me a wide-eyed WTF look and I made the last move possible - out the door behind her, calling after her, "Ms. Mitchell!" (sheesh), spinning a little blah blah blah and then, "May I take you to dinner tonight?" She said yes. I was not shocked, only upset that I had almost blown it.

There was no Internet then, for me to look up a few things about her, so I forgot about that famous interview she did that so angered her that she swore off any contact with the music press, an embargo that lasted nearly 10 years. So when, over drinks before dinner at a cool southwestern-style bar in Old Town, she asked what I did, and I answered honestly that I was a music critic, it's a wonder she didn't throw her drink in my face and storm out. (Which would have also been a good story.)

I found out over dinner (tiny place, tucked away, yes, romantic) that she had just returned from Mexico, working with Charles Mingus as he pursued radical treatment for his ALS (Lou Gehrig's Disease). I knew who Mingus was, but not enough to understand the import of what she was telling me. This had not made the news yet, that I was aware of, and I should have reacted with "What?! Please tell me all about it! What's he like? Could he still play? You wrote words? To Mingus songs?!" I'm sure she was looking for the reaction that did not come.

We had a pleasant enough evening but it did not meet my goal. She did not write a song about me the next morning, as I made her breakfast. (To be clear: there was no next morning.) I was way off my game, because of nervousness. I wasn't bad company, but Joni Mitchell deserves inspiration. She was probably thinking about her drive up to Abiquiu the next day, to visit another pretty good painter, Georgia O'Keefe.

If I had a moment with her at the Hammer, I would have first reminded her of the circumstances of our meeting to see if she remembered. If she didn't? - good laugh, another good part to the story. If she did, I was going to admit my off night as a worthy conversationalist and ask for another chance, another date. Only this time I would have brought my wife, also an accomplished professional singer and painter, who may be an even bigger Joni fan than I am. We'll go to the Mermaid Café, have fun tonight.

Charles Andrews has lived in Santa Monica for almost 30 years and wouldn't live anywhere else in the world. Really. You can reach him at therealmrmusic@gmail.com

Copyright protected material on this website is used in accordance with 'Fair Use', for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis, and will be removed at the request of the copyright owner(s). Please read Notice and Procedure for Making Claims of Copyright Infringement.

Added to Library on November 20, 2014. (2027)

Comments:

Log in to make a comment