Library of Articles

  • Library: Articles

Bare-bottomed Joni and mournful Melanie Print-ready version

by Philiip Crawley
Newcastle-upon-Tyne Journal
January 11, 1973
Original article: PDF

Joni Mitchell is well used to baring her soul for the sake of art.

On her new album “For the roses”, she goes one step further – by baring her bottom. The inside sleeve of the Asylum L.P. is a rear view of the blonde Canadian singer standing naked on the sea-shore.

Joni, whose lively love life has never quite over-shadowed her music, is an altogether uninhibited young lady – though her record company is more reserved. One four-letter word is replaced by a series of dots in the lyrics printed on the album cover.

As always, it’s the words that count on her albums. She is the voice of a generation in North America, expressing all the hopes, frustrations, furies and fads of young people in songs like “Woodstock”.

“For the roses” consists of frank reflections on her own emotions and ambitions, coupled with more general treatment of topics like drugs, pollution and social inequality.

It should be said that the poetry – and her writing does amount to that – is often better than the music, which mainly comprises the predictable combination of vocals, piano and guitar.

It tends to come alive with a little help from her famous friends, a retinue which over the years has included Neil Young, Al Kooper and James Taylor. Here there are musical contributions from Graham Nash, Stephen Stills and James Burton, who plays brilliant electric guitar on “Cold blue steel and sweet fire”.

No songs on this fine album come near the standard of “Both sides now” or “Big yellow taxi” but the Burton track, plus “Woman of heart and mind”, “Blonde in the bleachers” and “Banquet” alone would repay anyone’s investment.

“Stoneground words”, Melanie’s first album on her own Neighbourhood label, is a sad study in self-centred loneliness.

Her cracked, little girl’s voice brings out all the pathos of her own plight, though not everybody will summon up sympathy for a 26-year old New York girl who has managed to make so much money in the past five years.

Apart from plumbing her own emotions, Miss Safka’s songs have no other depths, but the musical backing, including organ and saxophone, is often inventive, with excellent effect on numbers like “Song of the South” and “Night Song”.

One grouse – why was it necessary to parcel it all up in such elaborate, expensive packaging?

Copyright protected material on this website is used in accordance with 'Fair Use', for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis, and will be removed at the request of the copyright owner(s). Please read Notice and Procedure for Making Claims of Copyright Infringement.

Added to Library on January 12, 2025. (2178)

Comments:

Log in to make a comment