Library of Articles

  • Library: Articles

Joni Mitchell- Latest offering is a pleasant whole Print-ready version

by Robert Murphy
San Pedro News Pilot
December 10, 1972
Original article: PDF

Joni Mitchell For The Roses" Asylum Records) — Why predictably successful performers switch record companies is a mystery known only to themselves and the corporate lawyers of both sides. How the change may affect their performance, their "artistic freedom", and eventually, their continued success, is just as much a mystery.

Some, like Joan Baez (Vanguard to A & M) become more "commercially appealing" at the expense of musical integrity. Others, like the Rolling Stones and the Beatles (respectively, London and Capitol to their own labels), become more adventuresome, at no cost to quality. Still others, like Delaney & Bonnie (Atco to Columbia), seem to change, thankfully, very little.

The latest addition to this last group is Joni Mitchell, once-Canadian folk singer, expert composer, one time "old lady" to practically every male name in modern music, and formerly a profitable part of Warner-Reprise Records.

"For the Roses" is her latest album, and first since joining Atlantic's Asylum Records, From its twelve cuts, one can say that, generally, only her employer has changed.

It has been about a year since "Blue," her last release for Reprise. Contrasts between it and "Roses" are difficult because of dominant similarities. Finally gone is Joni's fleeting penchant for the tritely cure up-tempo bits - most evident in "Yellow Taxi," less so by the time of "California" on "Blue," and not at all in the songs of "Roses." But, that seems more evolutionary in cause, anyway.

More tangibly attributable to her change of labels is the disappearance of less-than-lasting and less-than-uniform recording quality. Typically and annoyingly Reprise, were Joni Mitchell albums that would deteriorate in sound quality with each laying and with each cut toward the center of the record. With Miss Mitchell's talent for intricate lyrics, the loss of snap-crackle-pop distortion is not missed.

Overall, "Roses" holds no surprises for those accustomed to the musical directions of Joni Mitchell. Repetitive melodies serving as vehicles for far-reaching words still remain. Personal topics serving for anyone's understanding still do. The best of minimal instrumental accompaniment still complement lyrically-set tones.

There are no "hot tunes" singly-destined for million-sales. There are neither stand-outs nor throw-aways that can be discussed apart from the very pleasant whole.

Copyright protected material on this website is used in accordance with 'Fair Use', for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis, and will be removed at the request of the copyright owner(s). Please read Notice and Procedure for Making Claims of Copyright Infringement.

Added to Library on November 27, 2023. (1771)


Log in to make a comment