Library of Articles

  • Library: Articles

Dylan losing what Joni Mitchell has plenty of - Alienation Print-ready version

by Dale Anderson
Buffalo News
February 9, 1974
Original article: PDF

THERE USED TO BE age limits on alienation. To be meaningfully alienated, you had to be under 22 or so, like Holden Caulfield or James Dean or Bob Dylan at the start.

Dylan opened up a veritable Louisiana Purchase of alienation. His vistas of discontent stretched so far that folks needed months and years to reach that far themselves.

But lately there's been a dearth of worthwhile disaffection, despite attempts like Alice Cooper's "Teen-age Lament 1974" and Billy Joel's "Captain Jack," both of which dull their edge with mockery.

Still, it isn't the lack of contenders. Joni Mitchell's "Court And Spark" (Asylum 7E-1001 Elektra) is simply a brilliant and definite piece on what it's like to be at odds with the world and yourself in the '70s.

Her alienation isn't an innocent one. If anything, it's guilty. It's done a lot of places and been many things. Nor is it revolutionary. She doesn't want to overturn much. Just the way people fail to love one another and the way her own hopes and fears light off fulfillment.

THE OPENING title track dives right into it - a rejection of love because she's unwilling to trust it, unwilling to give to receive:

"The more he talked
The more he reached me
City of the fallen angels..."

So there's the failed attempt within the good-natured bounce of "Help Me" ("We love our lovin' But not like we love our freedom") and the self-imposed doom and regret of "Free Man In Paris" ("You know I'd go back there tomorrow. But for the work I've taken on ...").

In "People's Parties" there's sophisticated barriers protecting every helplessness but hers. "The Same Situation" shows in-security reigning in the privacy of a mirror:

"With the millions of the lost and
lonely and the lovely ones
I called out to be released
Caught in my struggle for
higher achievements
And my search for love
that don't seem to cease"

Lovers make her un-easy, like the one she waits for in "Car On A Hill" "makes friends easily/He's not like me/I watch for judgment anxiously."

The deceptively cheerful lady in lacy sleeves in "Raised On Robbery," the album's only all-out rocker, is dead-ended in Mitchell's dilemma, down from good times, wrecked on the rocks of romance, having even this cheap pickup. Then the bottom, the deep languor of "Trouble Child."

Up in a sterilized room
they can change the furniture
Knowing your attitude's all wrong
they'll rearrange
And you got to change
and that's not east..."

Which rides a clarinet into man the bright, self-righteous business of "Twisted," the old Lambert, Hendricks & Ross zonker that's sung like a horn solo. It ties up all her suffering in a saucy finish.

"Court And Spark" irons out the murky brooding of her previous "For The Roses" and gives it a sharp crease. Her rushing lyrics fall perfectly in place and the sidemen - Crosby and Stills, Robbie Robertson, Cheech & Chong are subtle delights.

In all, a desolate masterpiece.

THANKS TO his wife and children, Bob Dylan's gotten past alienation and created the system of values Mitchell longs for, an exclusive system that doesn't let much in. Behind that wall he's his own man.

"If I paid the price of solitude/At least then I'm out of debt," he sings in "Dirge," garnishing even this lesser song from "Planet Waves" (Asylum 7E-1003 Electra) with the wit and wisdom that give him that lean and prophetic look.

It's been a long time since the last real Dylan album, "New Morning," so there's much catching up to do. He welcomes you in to heat up some coffee grounds, to sit and hear the fire spark, to spend the night, "On a Night Like This."

"GOING, GOING, Gone" is a swansong to his old popstar life (I'm going before I get to the ledge), but it suggests also that you listen before he disappears. It's his duty to bring you back to the field where the flowers bloom. He hints in the rough and tumble of "Tough Mama."

"Forever Young" comes back to start side two in an irreverent upbeat version, as if Dylan's showing he's young enough to make a carnival of it.

A FRIEND says this cat alone makes the flip side her favorite, a brilliance that has to make us for the reduced voltage in the next three tracks. "Dirge" with melodrama from the past, "You Angel You" with its load of cliches and the good-natured meandering of "Never Say Good- bye."

"Wedding Song," a towering love song in his old apocalyptic manner, rescues the closing. The whole album feels like the old pre-Nashville Dylan, with all five members of the Band pumping and rocking behind him.

Copyright protected material on this website is used in accordance with 'Fair Use', for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis, and will be removed at the request of the copyright owner(s). Please read Notice and Procedure for Making Claims of Copyright Infringement.

Added to Library on March 1, 2025. (1594)

Comments:

Log in to make a comment